Whether this season is bringing you quality time with your S.O., best gals, or your family, there’s nothing like cuddling up under blankets for a movie night.

Enter the ever-present dilemma: Who gets to decide what to watch?

This handy flowchart will lead you to the perfect holiday pick with the precision of a March Madness bracket. And though it’s not an exact science, this will help you resolve the never-ending argument over whose turn it is to pick the movie.

From a mix of modern love tales to a dash of the classics—that are always Christmas-ready (although not always overtly), queue up one of these movies in front of the fire, wrapped in your favorite sweater on your living room couch.

121317_MOVIE FLOWCHART_v4-01