In a world of Harley Quinns, be a Rey.

If perusing the aisles of Party City only to find endless sexualized characters (and not much else) doesn’t have you in the Halloween spirit, fear not. Pinterest offers boundless inspiration for a creative yet affordable approach to your look by shopping your own closet first (and maybe the thrift store). Here are our favorites.

Rey // Star Wars

Mad Hatter // Alice in Wonderland

Arthur Read // Arthur

Barb & Eleven // Stranger Things

Jim & Pam // The Office

Carl & Ellie // Up